Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Unscented: The Top Choice for Good Cat Litter
After extensive testing of over 20 different cat litters across seven years, we’ve concluded that Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Unscented stands out as the best overall option. This litter provides an exceptional combination of odor control, clumping ability, and affordability, making it a top pick for cat owners. While no litter is without its drawbacks, Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Unscented consistently outperforms competitors in key areas important for maintaining a clean and fresh litter box.
This Good Cat Litter excels at forming firm, solid clumps that hold together effectively when scooping. The clumping action is superior to many other litters we evaluated, minimizing crumbles and making cleaning easier. The granule size is also ideal for cats’ paws, being gentle enough for sensitive felines, which increases the likelihood of acceptance and consistent litter box use. In terms of dust, Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Unscented presents a mid-range performance. It produces less dust during pouring compared to approximately half of the litters tested, and dust clouds are minimal during the scooping process, contributing to a healthier environment for both cats and owners.
However, Dr. Elsey’s Ultra does come in a large plastic bag which some users might find inconvenient to handle and pour from. Additionally, like many clumping litters, some clumps may occasionally stick to the bottom of the litter box, particularly if not cleaned regularly.
Buying Options
$21 from Chewy(40 pounds)
$21 from Amazon(40 pounds)
Arm & Hammer Super Scoop Clumping Litter: A Great Low-Dust Good Cat Litter Alternative
For cat owners who prioritize minimizing dust and tracking over ultimate clumping strength, Arm & Hammer Super Scoop Clumping Litter is an excellent alternative. This litter is highly effective at controlling odors and produces significantly less dust than most other clay-based litters we tested. The larger granules are designed to reduce dust and minimize tracking, meaning less litter scattered outside the box and a cleaner home. During pouring and scooping, the dust production is noticeably lower compared to many clay litters, making it a good choice for households sensitive to dust.
Arm & Hammer Super Scoop also offers good odor control and is packaged in a cardboard box, which many find easier to pour from and carry compared to plastic bags. However, it’s worth noting that the clumps formed by Arm & Hammer Super Scoop are not as robust as those of our top pick, Dr. Elsey’s Ultra. The clumps tend to be weaker and may break apart more easily during scooping, potentially leaving smaller soiled pieces behind in the litter box.
Buying Options
$20 from Chewy(40 pounds)
$20 from Petco(40 pounds)
World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Unscented: A Solid Non-Clay Good Cat Litter Choice
Clay-alternative cat litters are gaining popularity, and World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Unscented is a leading brand in this category. Made from whole kernel corn grown in the USA, this litter offers a different approach to cat litter. Our tests revealed that World’s Best Cat Litter excels in clumping and produces very minimal dust, making it a good option for those seeking a non-clay, low-dust good cat litter. However, it’s important to note that its odor control is not as strong as traditional clay litters.
Similar to Dr. Elsey’s Ultra, World’s Best Cat Litter is packaged in a plastic, non-resealable bag, which can be challenging for pouring and storage. Despite this packaging issue, World’s Best Cat Litter performs well with regular scooping and is a viable option for cat owners looking to move away from clay-based litters. We anticipate further testing of non-clay litters in the future to broaden our recommendations in this growing segment.
Buying Options
$22 from Chewy(28 pounds)May be out of stock
$40 from Amazon(32 pounds)
DurAnimals DuraScoop Original Cat Litter Scoop: The Best Scoop for Good Cat Litter Maintenance
Maintaining a clean litter box is crucial for both hygiene and your cat’s well-being. The right scoop can make this task significantly easier and less unpleasant. Among eight scoops we tested, the DurAnimals DuraScoop Original Cat Litter Scoop emerged as the top choice. This scoop is designed to minimize mess and streamline the scooping process, making it an essential tool for any cat owner using good cat litter. After scooping multiple heavy loads, the DuraScoop exhibited minimal residue buildup, with very little urine or litter crust sticking to the edge and no litter particles becoming trapped in the slats.
The generous size and robust construction of the DuraScoop allow for quick and efficient raking through the litter box, effectively capturing most clumps. Its design helps to make the often-undesirable chore of litter box cleaning as efficient and tolerable as possible.
Buying Options
$13 from Chewy
Buy from Amazon
$13 from Walmart
iPrimio Non-Stick Litter Scooper: A Narrow-Slat Alternative for Good Cat Litter
For those who prefer a scoop that can capture even the smaller soiled litter particles that might fall back into the pan, the iPrimio Non-Stick Litter Scooper is a highly recommended alternative. This scoop features narrower slats, which are effective at sifting out finer waste. While the slats can occasionally clog, we found them to be easily cleared, maintaining the scoop’s efficiency.
Slightly smaller than our top pick, the DuraScoop, the iPrimio scoop’s slender shape allows it to reach into tight corners of the litter box while still being capable of efficiently combing through larger litter boxes. The non-stick surface further aids in easy cleaning and prevents buildup, making it a practical choice for managing good cat litter.
Buying Options
$20 from Amazon
