Having multiple cats brings double, triple, or even more the love and companionship into your home. However, it also means dealing with a significantly busier litter box. If you’re finding yourself constantly battling odors and struggling to keep up with litter box maintenance, you’re not alone. The key to a harmonious multi-cat household often lies in choosing the Best Multi Cat Litter. While even the best cat litter box can become overwhelmed with multiple feline users, the right litter designed for multi-cat homes can make a world of difference. It can help you extend the time between complete litter changes to approximately once a week, provided you choose a high-quality product formulated for the task.
Fortunately, the market offers a variety of excellent cat litters specifically engineered for multi-cat environments. We’ve rigorously tested and reviewed numerous options to bring you our top recommendations, helping you find the best multi cat litter to conquer odors and keep both you and your feline family happy.
Why Trust Cats.com for Multi-Cat Litter Reviews?
Testing-Cat-Litter for multiple cats
At Cats.com, we are committed to providing cat owners with reliable and unbiased information. Our team, including experienced cat product testers like Mallory Crusta, has personally invested in and rigorously evaluated over two dozen of the most popular cat litter brands and more than 50 individual litter products. We purchase all products at full retail price, ensuring our reviews are completely independent and free from any influence from the companies themselves. Our testing process is entirely funded by Cats.com, reflecting our dedication to honest and helpful reviews.
Our Thorough Cat Litter Testing Methodology
To provide you with the most accurate and practical recommendations for the best multi cat litter, we follow a comprehensive testing process:
- Real-World Purchase: We buy cat litter products available on the market, just as a regular consumer would.
- Extended Home Testing: We test each litter in real home environments with multiple cats for a minimum of ten days. This allows us to observe performance under typical household conditions.
- Multi-Sensory Evaluation: We assess various aspects of each litter, starting with its initial appearance, granule size, scent (if any), and dust level when pouring.
- Performance Metrics: Crucially, we evaluate odor control effectiveness, ease of scooping clumps, and the degree of litter tracking outside the box.
- Cat Preference Observation: Our own cats play a vital role in the evaluation. Their preferences and usage patterns provide valuable insights into the palatability and comfort of each litter.
By combining objective assessments with observations of real-world cat usage, we ensure our recommendations for the best multi cat litter are truly helpful and reflect practical performance in your home.
At a Glance: Top Multi Cat Litter Picks
950 hours of research
38 brands vetted
8 features reviewed
8 top picks
For a quick comparison, here’s a snapshot of our top recommendations for the best multi cat litter. The table below highlights key features of each product. Continue reading for detailed reviews of each litter.
| Overall Best | Best Natural | Best for Odor Control | Best Low-Tracking | Best Premium | Best Lightweight | Best Scented | Best Unscented |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 aac-table__image Dr. Elsey’s Ultra-Premium |
Top 8 Best Cat Litters for Multiple Cats: Detailed Reviews
For homes with more than one feline friend, finding the best multi cat litter is essential. These top-rated litters excel in key areas like odor control and minimizing tracking, ensuring your home stays fresh and clean, even with multiple cats using the litter box. Let’s dive into the specifics of each recommendation:
#1 Overall Best Multi Cat Litter: World’s Best Cat Litter
World’s Best Cat Litter
Shop Now: $33.75 at Chewy or $18.35 at Amazon
Read our full brand review: World’s Best Cat Litter Review
World’s Best Cat Litter truly lives up to its name, consistently ranking as a top choice for multi-cat households. Made from natural, compressed corn kernels, this clumping litter is naturally free of silica dust, promoting a healthier respiratory environment for both you and your cats.
World’s-Best-Cat-Litter-Clumping-Formula
Its exceptional clumping action forms remarkably tight and hard clumps upon contact with urine and feces. This makes scooping incredibly easy and efficient, minimizing mess and litter waste. Being biodegradable and flushable (always check local regulations), disposal is also convenient and eco-friendly. Furthermore, this unscented litter effectively eliminates and prevents odors, making it a powerful solution for multi-cat homes.
World
While it comes at a higher price point compared to many other litters, the superior performance and odor control of World’s Best Cat Litter justify the investment for many multi-cat owners seeking the best multi cat litter. It’s no surprise that it’s consistently recommended as one of our top picks for overall best cat litter.
Worlds-Best-Cat-Litter-Multiple-Cat-Unscented…
What We Liked:
- Forms incredibly hard, tight clumps for easy scooping.
- Very low dust, free from silica dust.
- Eco-friendly and all-natural, clumps are flushable (where regulations allow).
What We Didn’t Like:
- Lightweight corn kernels can track slightly more than heavier litters.
- Premium price point.
#2 Best Natural Multi Cat Litter: Catalyst Pet Multi-Cat Formula Cat Litter
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $12.35 per month at CatalystPet or $23.99 at Chewy
Read our full brand review: Catalyst Cat Litter Review
For environmentally conscious cat owners, Catalyst Pet Multi-Cat Formula Cat Litter stands out as the best natural multi cat litter choice. This innovative litter is made from upcycled softwood fiber, a renewable resource that would otherwise be wasted. Available in Healthy Cat, Unscented, and Multi-Cat formulas, Catalyst Pet litter is remarkably dust-free (99%), lightweight, and gentle on sensitive paws thanks to its fine-grained texture.
Catalyst Multi-Cat Formula
Despite its lightweight nature, Catalyst Pet delivers impressive clumping and odor control, making it highly effective in multi-cat homes. It’s also free from crystalline silica dust, further enhancing its appeal as a healthy and natural option.
Catalyst Multi-Cat Formula
An added benefit is its efficiency – one pound of Catalyst litter can perform the work of three pounds of traditional clumping clay litter. Choosing the 40 lb option offers excellent value, costing approximately $12.35 per month and lasting at least 4 months for a single cat, making it a surprisingly affordable best natural multi cat litter solution.
Catalyst Multi-Cat Formula
What We Liked:
- Excellent odor control.
- Fine-grained texture is soft and paw-friendly.
- Made from renewable resources and doesn’t contain crystalline silica dust.
What We Didn’t Like:
- May track slightly.
#3 Best Multi Cat Litter for Odor Control: Arm & Hammer Multi-Cat Clump & Seal Clumping Litter
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $12.42 at Chewy
Read our full brand review: Arm & Hammer Cat Litter Review
Odor control is paramount in multi-cat households, and Arm & Hammer Multi-Cat Clump & Seal Clumping Litter is specifically designed to tackle this challenge, earning its spot as the best multi cat litter for odor control. This litter harnesses the renowned odor-fighting power of Arm & Hammer baking soda, combined with moisture-activated microgranules. These granules effectively seal in odors from feces, urine, and ammonia, promising an odor-free litter box for up to a full 7 days.
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Multi-Cat Formula Cat Litter review
Furthermore, its very low dust formula minimizes tracking and mess around the litter box. While the sandy texture might be initially off-putting to some cats, the powerful odor control of Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal is undeniable, even when tested with three cats sharing litter boxes.
What We Liked:
- Forms hard clumps to trap and eliminate odors, simplifying cleanup.
- Baking soda provides reliable odor protection for a full week.
- Very low dust and low tracking for less mess.
What We Didn’t Like:
- Sandy texture might not be preferred by all cats.
- Clumps can sometimes break apart during scooping.
#4 Best Low-Tracking Multi Cat Litter: tuft + paw Really Great Cat Litter
Tuft-Paw-Really-Great-Cat-Litter
Shop Now: $29 at tuft + paw
Read our full brand review: tuft + paw Cove Litter Box Review
If litter tracking is a major concern in your multi-cat home, tuft + paw Really Great Cat Litter is the best low-tracking multi cat litter solution. Unlike many low-tracking litters that are dense and heavy, Really Great Cat Litter is surprisingly lightweight. Made from soybean byproduct and formed into unique, oblong pellets, the shape and size of these pellets significantly reduce litter scatter outside the box.
Tuft & Paw Really Great Cat Litter
While it is a premium-priced litter, Really Great Cat Litter offers several unique benefits. It’s biodegradable, compostable, and even flushable (with proper soaking before flushing). In terms of performance, this natural litter quickly absorbs liquids and forms cohesive clumps that are easy to scoop.
Tuft & Paw Really Great Cat Litter
While the clumps might be slightly more delicate than those formed by clay litter, careful scooping prevents them from breaking apart. Cats generally accept the pellet texture, and the formula effectively controls odor without added fragrances.
Tuft & Paw Really Great Cat Litter
What We Liked:
- Biodegradable, compostable, and flushable for eco-conscious disposal.
- Lightweight, low-tracking pellets minimize mess.
- Forms easy-to-scoop clumps.
What We Didn’t Like:
- Subscription-only purchase model.
- Significantly more expensive than average cat litters.
#5 Best Premium Multi Cat Litter: Pretty Litter Ultra-Premium Cat Litter Subscription
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $26.99 at PrettyLitter or $26.99 at Chewy
Read our full brand review: Pretty Litter Review
Pretty Litter Ultra-Premium Cat Litter Subscription earns the title of best premium multi cat litter due to its unique health-monitoring capabilities and excellent performance. This lightweight silica crystal litter is dust-free and features a fine texture that’s gentle on even the most sensitive cat paws.
Pretty Litter
Delivered conveniently through a monthly subscription, a single bag of Pretty Litter is designed to last up to 30 days for one cat. For multi-cat households, simply add an extra litter box per cat. The silica crystals excel at absorbing odor and eliminating moisture, dehydrating solid waste for easy maintenance and a consistently clean litter box.
pouring pretty litter
While Pretty Litter is more expensive than many alternatives, its standout feature is its ability to change color based on urine pH levels. This can provide early alerts to potential health issues, allowing for timely veterinary intervention. For proactive cat owners, this health-monitoring aspect makes Pretty Litter a worthwhile premium choice.
Pretty Litter
What We Liked:
- Color-changing crystals can signal changes in your cat’s urine, aiding in early health issue detection.
- Lightweight silica material with a soft, sand-like texture.
- Dehydrates solid waste and eliminates liquid waste for effective odor control.
What We Didn’t Like:
- A single bag might not last a full month in multi-cat homes.
- Relatively expensive, particularly compared to other silica-based litters.
#6 Best Lightweight Multi Cat Litter: Cat’s Pride Complete Care Unscented Hypoallergenic Multi-Cat Clumping Litter
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $27.99 at Amazon
Read our full brand review: Cat’s Pride Cat Litter Review
Cat’s Pride Complete Care Unscented Hypoallergenic Multi-Cat Clumping Litter is the best lightweight multi cat litter, offering a fragrance-free and allergen-free option ideal for sensitive cats and owners alike. Its unscented nature is particularly beneficial for cats who are averse to strong fragrances often found in natural cat litters. Being hypoallergenic, it minimizes the risk of allergic reactions and sensitivities, ensuring comfort for all cats in your household.
Cat
Beyond its gentle formula, Cat’s Pride Complete Care effectively eliminates odors quickly, providing lasting freshness in the litter box area. However, it’s worth noting that this litter can track more than some other options and may require more frequent cleaning around the litter box.
What We Liked:
- Fast-acting odor elimination.
- Ideal for sensitive cats due to its unscented and hypoallergenic formula.
- Allergen-free.
What We Didn’t Like:
- Can be prone to tracking and mess.
#7 Best Scented Multi Cat Litter: Jonny Cat Complete Multi-Cat Clay Litter Bag
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $28.48 at Amazon
Jonny Cat Complete Multi-Cat Clay Litter Bag is the best scented multi cat litter for those who prefer a scented option and are seeking a budget-friendly choice. It’s a potent litter capable of handling multiple cats effectively, and it’s one of the most affordable litters on our list. Jonny Cat boasts a powerful odor guard and long-lasting odor protection.
However, its primary drawback is tracking. Jonny Cat is known to track significantly, and you’ll likely need to clean up tracked litter frequently. The degree of tracking can vary depending on your cats’ habits, so consider your cats’ litter box behavior before choosing Jonny Cat as your best scented multi cat litter.
What We Liked:
- Highly cost-effective cat litter.
- Powerful odor control.
- Long-lasting odor protection.
What We Didn’t Like:
- Significant tracking can lead to mess.
#8 Best Unscented Multi Cat Litter: Dr. Elsey’s Cat Ultra-Premium Clumping Cat Litter
aac-table__image
Shop Now: $20.99 at Chewy or $20.99 at Amazon
Read our full brand review: Dr. Elsey’s Cat Litter Review
Dr. Elsey’s Cat Ultra-Premium Clumping Cat Litter is our pick for the best unscented multi cat litter, particularly for health-conscious cat owners. Many clay litters contain silica dust, a known respiratory irritant with long-term exposure risks. Dr. Elsey’s is specifically formulated to minimize respiratory issues. It is hypoallergenic, very low in dust, and completely free of perfumes and deodorants.
Dr. Elsey
This clay litter also includes natural essences designed to reduce stress in cats. Its exceptional clumping action virtually eliminates dust and simplifies cleaning, making it an excellent choice for multi-cat households seeking a healthy and low-maintenance best unscented multi cat litter.
Dr. Elsey
While its odor control might not be as potent as some competitors, its health benefits and dust-free nature make Dr. Elsey’s a top contender.
Dr. Elsey
What We Liked:
- Low-dust formula designed to prevent respiratory problems.
- Hard-clumping action effectively locks in odor and moisture.
- Hypoallergenic, free of perfumes and deodorants, and contains stress-reducing natural essences.
What We Didn’t Like:
- Odor control is not as strong as some other litters.
- Can become sticky when wet and adhere to the litter box sides.
Key Considerations When Choosing Multi Cat Litter
12 Best clumping Cat Litters 2024-11
Selecting the best multi cat litter involves more than just odor control. Keep these crucial factors in mind to ensure you and your feline family are happy with your choice:
-
Adequate Number of Litter Boxes: In multi-cat homes, the rule of thumb is to have one more litter box than the number of cats. Providing multiple litter boxes is essential to prevent territorial disputes and ensure all cats have comfortable and accessible bathroom options. Cat behaviorist Melina Grin emphasizes that having multiple boxes can significantly reduce inter-cat aggression and stress related to litter box access.
-
Cat Preference Matters: Cats can be surprisingly particular about their litter. Some prefer clumping, others non-clumping. Scented or unscented preferences also vary. Be prepared for some trial and error to discover what your cats prefer and will consistently use.
-
Consider Cat Allergies and Sensitivities: Just like humans, cats can have allergies. Certain litter ingredients can trigger sensitivities. Carefully review litter ingredients, particularly if your cat has known allergies. If you suspect a reaction after introducing a new litter, switch back to a known safe option immediately.
Further Reading: 5 Best Pet Stain And Odor Removers
We hope this guide to the best multi cat litter helps you find the perfect solution for your home. By carefully considering the advantages and disadvantages of each recommended litter, you can create a fresher, cleaner, and more harmonious environment for you and your beloved multi-cat family. Remember, the right litter can significantly reduce stress for both you and your feline companions in a multi-cat household.
This article’s veterinary information has been reviewed for medical accuracy. However, the reviewing veterinarian does not personally endorse or recommend any specific products mentioned.
